Oh, man—that certainly is a frustrating situation, isn’t it? It’s enough to make a pitcher tear his or her hair out by the roots. But there is a solution to this problem. Take a deep breath and decide that the next day there is going to be the first of a series of intensive fielding practice sessions. And if need be, you direct them. Everything from fielding bunts to pulling down high line drives to turning double plays.
Here’s a nice little drill for catchers on handling high pop-ups—a couple of years ago I saw this one at spring training in Tampa. Jorge Posada demonstrated this one: a batting machine—or a batter if you don’t have a machine handy—popped one high in the air and Posada had to catch it. Then two balls—then three, then four, one right after the other in rapid succession. Every catcher in camp had to do it. And on one occasion I had to laugh, because one kid lost his balance and fell over on his tush with his arms and legs up in the air like an overturned bug and I was instantly reminded of what I used to see 8) happening to a lot of batters who struck out trying to get a piece of my slider!
You can ask one of your coaches to devise a series of these exercises and drills so that you can set about teaching your fielders how to do things properly without being butterfingered.