I had to go with Chris Carpenter, but if i voted for Cy Young i'd give my vote to Pettitte. Why? he's got a 2.39 ERA (better than Willis and Carpenter) to go with his 17-9 Record (4 More wins than clemens, 1 more loss, unsuperior to Willis and Carpenter). Sure he lacks in other categories (7K/9IP for example) he still put up a really strong season, so i'd give it to him. And to add to that, Pettitte put up a much better postseason game than Clemens did so far. Plus, i like the Astros but dislike Clemens so consider me a tad biased.
who i think will win it:
Who i think should win it:
Who i want to win it:
HM:Peavy & Clemens
As for AL, I'm going to give it to Santana for obvious reasons. HM include Rivera and Colon. As for who i think is going to get it...i haven't thought about it too much. AL Cy Young is less exciting than NL this year. If only Halladay was healthy, he'd have stolen the Cy Young the way he was pitching before he got injured (Heck, he'd be giving the NL Pitchers a run for their money stat-wise)